Written in 1787 by Royall Tyler, “The Contrast” holds the distinction of being America’s first comedy and an undeniable smash hit in its day. Now, Philadelphia Artists’ Collective brings this revolutionary romp back to life in a fresh production directed by Ann Garner.
Part romantic comedy, part social satire, “The Contrast” helped define what “American manners” would become. With wit as sharp as a powdered wig pin and a keen eye on the cultural tug-of-war between European influence and homegrown integrity, this 18th-century gem will leave you in stitches.
Set in the aftermath of the American Revolution, the play skewers fashion, flirtation, and the cultural tug-of-war between European polish and emerging American identity. The sentimental Maria, played by Brittany Onukwugha, is unhappily engaged to the extravagantly Europeanized Mr. Dimple, portrayed by James Kern, a preening dandy whose imported tastes and wandering eye threaten more than just his fiancée’s happiness. Jenna Kuerzi appears as the sharp Charlotte, with Eliza Carson as her friend Letitia, while Nathan Foley plays the pragmatic Van Rough. Zachary Valdez takes on the role of Colonel Manly, the principled Revolutionary War hero whose moral clarity stands in stark contrast to Dimple. He is joined by Kevin McCann as Jonathan, Manly’s quickwitted and plainspoken servant. The company is rounded out by Brandon Tyler as Jessamy and Megan McDermott as Jenny.
I’ve loved this play since I read it over a decade ago. Right now, during the Semiquincentennial, and at a moment in our nation’s history that feels bewildering to many, I’m excited about the opportunity to delve into what was on the minds of newly minted Americans, people who would set the tone and values for the next generations. Producing this wildly popular play from 1787 gives us direct access to that culture, and to get to do that with such an entertaining play is a joy. – Director Ann Garner.
More than two centuries later, “The Contrast” still asks: What makes us American? Is it style or substance? Flash or fortitude?
If You Go
Dates: April 9 – 26, 2026*
Press Opening: April 12 at 3:00pm
Venue: Louis Bluver Theatre at The Drake
Address: 302 S. Hicks Street, Philadelphia PA 19102
Link: www.philartistscollective.org/
*This event is part of Philly Theatre Week! A limited number of Pay What You Can tickets are available for the April 24 & 25 performances.
Post expires at 8:36pm on Monday April 27th, 2026